Doug is the founder of Werman Salas P.C. A focus of his legal practice are class and...
Reed Russell works with clients on complex wage and hour issues, representing them across the country in...
Matt Greer is a long-time labor relations neutral and member of the ABA Labor and Employment Law Section. In...
| Published: | November 17, 2026 |
| Podcast: | ABA Labor and Employment Law Podcast |
| Category: | News & Current Events |
In this episode, we take a deep dive into fair labor standards issues, including areas that may (or sometimes may not) require judicial oversight and approval, even if workers agree to waive some hourly and wage rights. Guests Reed Russell and Douglas Werman are both navigating the shifting labor and employment law issues buried in the Fair Labor Standards Act (FLSA).
Even now, nearly 90 years since the FLSA’s passage, disputes continue to be litigated over wage and overtime rates and rules. The laws continue to evolve with each court review. With many claims being “settled” rather than ruled on, there can be murky areas. When a worker agrees to a settlement, but there wasn’t court or agency oversight, can it be enforced? It depends.
When is an agreement an agreement? And when is it binding? Sometimes that comes down to the judge.
Not only does case law muddy the waters, some decisions regarding labor and hourly standards and settlements can vary by a judge’s interpretations. This is where labor and employment attorneys truly earn their pay.
REFERENCES MENTIONED:
“The Fair Labor Standards Act (FLSA): An Overview,” Congress.gov
“D. A. Schulte, Inc. V. Gangi 328 U.S. 108 (1946),” Findlaw.com
“Brooklyn Savings Bank v. O’Neil, 324 U.S. 697 (1945),” Justia
“E.M.D. Sales, Inc. v. Carrera, 604 U.S. (2025),” Justia
“Martin v. Spring Break ’83 Prods., LLC (5th Cir. 2012),” Justia
“Federal Courts Split on Legality of the FTC’s NonCompete Rule,” Congress.gov
“29 U.S.C. § 216 – U.S. Code – Unannotated Title 29. Labor § 216. Penalties,” FindLaw.com
“Title VII of the Civil Rights Act of 1964,” EEOC.gov
Special thanks to our sponsor ABA Labor and Employment Law Section .
Matt Greer:
How often do you have to consider whether your judge agrees with the settlement you’ve reached? In this episode, guests Reed Russell and Doug Worman dig into the unexpected complexities of settling Fair Labor Standards Act wage claims. They unpack how circuit splits and individual judicial approaches can trigger the need for court approval to deem a settlement fair and reasonable. They share practical tips to help parties secure true finality in their agreements. Hello, and welcome to the ABA Labor and Employment Law Podcast. I’m your host, Matt Greer. In my day job, I work for the Washington State Public Employment Relations Commission, where I spend most of my time serving as a public sector labor relations mediator, hearing examiner, arbitrator, and trainer, always as a neutral. Probably like you, my focus area is one small piece of the bigger labor and employment law universe. I enjoy broadening my horizons through this podcast and learning about what’s going on in the wide world of labor and employment law from experts in the field.
Matt Greer:
On today’s episode, I’m very happy to welcome Reed Russell, and Doug Worman to discuss the complexities that arise when litigating Fair Labor Standards Act cases, including circumstances where parties need to get court approval when they reach a settlement of those claims. Doug represents employees as a partner at the law firm of Worman Salas based in Chicago. Reed represents employers as a partner at the Phelps Law Firm based in Tampa, Florida. It’s great having them both on the podcast to share their expertise. Be sure to check out their full bios in the show notes. Thank you so much for joining us, Reed and Doug. Welcome to the show.
Doug Werman:
Thanks, Matt. Really excited to be here. Appreciate you including me today. Yeah, likewise. Thank you, Matt. Happy to be here. Looking forward to the discussion.
Matt Greer:
Great. So as we’re talking about, you know, Fair Labor Standards Act, I mean, some of our listeners I’m sure have heard of that before, but it may have been a while for some folks since they’ve had to kind of think about FLSA situations and what’s actually going on with that law. Reed, I understand that you might have some unique kind of perspective or some background in kind of giving us a bit of a quick primer reminder about what the Fair Labor Standards Act even is and what kind of drives it and why we’re even talking about it today. So I don’t know, do you want to give us a little bit of a background and kind of set the table for our conversation?
Reed Russell:
Sure. The Fair Labor Standards Act of 1938 is one of a number of New Deal-era social welfare statutes that were passed during the FDR administration and may be saved by the switch in time that saves 9, as some people would say, or otherwise would’ve been an unconstitutional incursion on the freedom of contract. But it has survived. And as we get into the neighborhood, not quite 100 years, but approaching 100 years in the next 12, it’s surprising how much litigation continues to revolve around that. And what the Fair Labor Standards Act does is require a baseline federal minimum wage that applies to not every, but most employers in the United States, and also requires the payment of overtime for hours worked over 40 in a week at time and a half what they call the regular rate, which is not necessarily just the minimum wage. It’s the wage rate at which people are actually paid. And that issue itself is often the subject of a lot of litigation. So what the regular rate actually is, it’s a surprisingly difficult-to-comply-with statute, at least from employers’ perspective, given a statute that’s been around for so long, generates a lot of litigation, and thus results also in a lot of litigated settlements or negotiated settlements, which we’ll talk about more today.
Matt Greer:
Yeah, thanks for that background. Doug, did you get it? Did you have anything you wanted to add on that piece?
Doug Werman:
Even though the law is 80-plus years old now, you know, I feel like the statute was really just discovered by the plaintiffs’ bar maybe in the late 1990s or 2000s, really when the majority of the litigations really happened. And over the last, you know, 30 years, the law continues to develop, and it’s a very exciting area for me to still practice in. I mean, I know Reed is one of these individuals, and I am too, that lawyers that just live and breathe the statute. And it’s fun to practice in it as it continues to evolve.
Matt Greer:
Fun even, huh? Okay. That’s good to hear. It’s nice to hear somebody’s in an area where they practice where they can describe it as fun. So Reed didn’t say that word. I don’t know. I won’t put words in his mouth, but, but maybe.
Reed Russell:
It is an interesting area and surprisingly it’s like sometimes like peeling an onion, which can be fun, but also sad.
Matt Greer:
Yeah. Okay.
Reed Russell:
Gotcha.
Doug Werman:
And that’s what we’re here to talk about today is one of the areas where the law is continuing to evolve and is actually continuing to evolve really quickly. And, you know, there were these decisions that are now, you know, 80-plus years old that I think courts, especially the circuit courts, are starting to finally begin to grapple with in terms of, you know, it’s easy to file these cases. And I think most lawyers in the practice area know about the explosive number of cases that have been filed in the last 20 or 30 years, but it’s easy to file them. And now I think courts are really beginning to grapple with how do you resolve them? How do you settle them? And how do you bring finality to the litigations?
Matt Greer:
And that might be what surprises some of our listeners to hear about that. That was kind of the impetus for the episode is that there have been some developing splits in the courts in terms of how these cases do get settled and the court’s involvement in that. So I don’t know, do one of you want to kind of take the lead on that and kind of give us a context for what’s happening in terms of the settlement approval
Reed Russell:
Maybe I’d just make a baseline point is that I think a lot of employers and even employees who bring cases may have been involved in litigation before and settled cases involving their employees or with their employer. And a lot of those settlements or resolutions are just done with a private agreement between the employee and the employer. It’s signed off on by, after consulting with your counsel. And then if there’s been a case filed, it’s just dismissed, right? And it goes away. And the FLSA, at least as the way that a lot of courts have handled it, have imposed a requirement in many cases that the court where it’s pending review that settlement and approve it to make sure that it’s what they call fair and reasonable. And that’s been the subject of a lot of dispute about whether that should happen. Is that appropriate? And that area is developing, and that’s what I think we’re going to talk about some more today.
Doug Werman:
So when lawyers are saying that, you know, FLSA settlements require court approval, from my perspective, there’s really 3 sort of distinct concepts are being collapsed oftentimes into one thing. One is, you know, is a private settlement enforceable at all? Can an employee privately release FLSA minimum wage or overtime rights without some kind of supervision, whether it be Department of Labor supervision or judicial supervision. Another issue is the dismissal procedure. So, you know, if an FLSA case is already pending, can the parties just file a Rule 41 or dismissal with or without prejudice? and have that dismissal be self-executing, or whether or not is a court going to police that? And then there are now many cases, especially cases coming out of the Second Circuit, where the courts that believe that they have to review the settlement is what’s the scope of that review? Is it just a review of the release of the FLSA claims, or they’re also reviewing things like the attorney’s fees or the confidentiality provisions, service awards, nondisparagement. So the scope of the review is yet another issue. And so you’ve all 3 of these issues kind of collapsing into one that district courts and now circuit courts are beginning to address now in a more rigorous way.
Matt Greer:
Yeah, that sounds awfully complex. I mean, not being in this area, it sounds like almost some of those issues might be as complex to resolve as the underlying claims, perhaps. But yeah, it’s really, really fascinating. Thanks for kind of crystallizing it that way.
Reed Russell:
It can have a little bit of a tail wagging the dog element to it because the approval requirement that we see where it exists exists even in an individual resolution of an FLSA case. So one guy bringing a claim, claiming that he was underpaid, either not paid all his overtime or wasn’t paid minimum wage, and that gets resolved. Even that individual claim, which may only be worth a few thousand dollars plus attorney’s fees, will have to be reviewed. Certainly where I am in Florida, it’s well settled that you have to take those to court and get them reviewed. And so you can spend as much or more time on the review process as you did on the resolution. So as a result, there’s some resistance by employers in looking for ways to get courts to let them out of that process, right? And so it is complicated.
Doug Werman:
Reed, how did this all start? What’s the genesis of this?
Reed Russell:
Depending on how far back you go, I think a lot of listeners may have heard, if they’ve practiced any FLSA law at all, of an 11th Circuit case called Linz Food. And in that case, the 11th Circuit, there was a private settlement, a purported private settlement between an employer and its employees following a Department of Labor investigation. And they did settlements and the employees signed releases and then sued. And the employer said, no, no, no, you already released these claims. And the 11th Circuit ultimately said, no, no, no, those weren’t released because they weren’t approved and reviewed by the court. And it looked to a couple of older Supreme Court cases One, Brooklyn Savings versus O’Neill, and then D.A. Schulte v. Ganji, that had put limits on the ability to waive FLSA claims in a private setting.
Reed Russell:
And the 11th Circuit, and it has been this way since I think that was a 1982 decision, has said you have to have court approval or Department of Labor oversight. to have a settlement of an FLSA claim and have it be binding. And that is a very oversimplified, super oversimplified explanation of it, but going into these cases for employers, that’s kind of what you have to have your eye on as you move forward.
Doug Werman:
So I agree that the lawyers are generally talking about Lynn’s Foods as, you know, where this principle or where this rule originated, but You know, as Reed mentioned, I think that you really need to go back and look at the early Supreme Court decisions. I think Brooklyn Savings versus O’Neill was decided in 1945. And it’s that case that the Supreme Court held that minimum labor standards cannot be waived. It’s a non-waivability rule. And then the Supreme Court later developed that further in Ganji, the Schulte versus Ganji decision, even though, you know, we’re talking about the 1980 decision in Lynn’s Food. I mean, you even have Supreme Court decisions in 2013 and 2025, the Simchuk case and the EMD decision in 2025, where the Supreme Court is also saying that, you know, maximum hours cannot be modified by contract. And the EMD decision, the Supreme Court said that at least some FLSA rights are not waivable. And so where these cases and where these Supreme Court decisions then bleed into the more modern district court and circuit court decisions is, what’s the practical effect or how do you implement this rule that the Supreme Court has said these statutory rights that are not waivable?
Reed Russell:
And I understand that. And I think where employers have kind of, they see that and they hear that kind of broad statement and they go back and they look at Brooklyn Savings and they look at Schulte and they say, wait a minute, Brooklyn Savings said you couldn’t waive your right to liquidated damages, but there was no dispute over that the wages themselves were owed. And then in Ganji, they said you can’t waive Coverage, whether you’re covered under the statute. But both cases left the question unanswered about whether you could have a private resolution where there’s a bona fide dispute over the amount owed. And that’s often, from an employer’s perspective, where the rubber meets the road. They’re not saying you’re not entitled to minimum wage because the statute says it. and you would be entitled to overtime if you worked it, right? If we suffered or permitted it. But there’s a dispute about whether you’re owed it.
Reed Russell:
And so they say there’s still a gap from the employer’s perspective that has run up against a brick wall in the 11th Circuit. Okay? Multiple times the 11th Circuit has had an opportunity to narrow or walk away from Linz Foods, and it has turned that down. But there is still this argument about whether you can have a private settlement. The Fifth Circuit has addressed this and come out the other way. It didn’t disagree with Lynn’s Foods, but limited it to its factual situation and has said, well, if you’ve got a bona fide dispute over the amounts owed, and we would say, and if you’re represented, you’re not a pro se plaintiff, you’re not an unrepresented party, then the parties should be able to work that out just like they would a Title VII claim.
Doug Werman:
But even, even the Fifth Circuit has put limits on its own rules because the Fifth Circuit in its Martin v. Spring Break case, you know, identified the fact that there needs to be a bona fide dispute and the parties are represented. And then later it issued, I think it’s the Boitel decision, where the— it was pre-litigation and the court found that that was not sufficient to constitute a release and waiver of the FLSA claims.
Reed Russell:
Yeah, I thought the problem with Bogle, I mean, I wish they hadn’t issued it, but they did. But what Bogle dealt with was the defendant in Bogle, the company TGX, had sued 2 of its employees for violating a non-compete agreement. And those 2 employees had counterclaimed for a declaratory judgment saying the non-compete agreement is invalid. And so the parties then reached a settlement and the employer included in the release a release of FLSA claims. But there was no dispute in the underlying non-compete litigation about wage and hour. There was no claim by those employees that they had been underpaid or whatever. So when they brought the FLSA claim and the employer said, well, we already resolved it and see Martin v. Spring Break, and we can have private settlements, the Fifth Circuit said, that’s not the case here.
Reed Russell:
You didn’t have a dispute About, certainly not one that was public or anyone knew about, right? You have to have it. It needs to be crystallized. So it does raise an issue with respect to severance agreements that employers may give to an employee when, you know, it’s like, hey, we’re laying you off. You’ve been a good employee. Here’s a severance package and here’s a release. And it includes an FLSA claims release. But the employee’s just walking out the door, right, having been a loyal employee and now just taking a severance package. They haven’t said, oh, I think I’ve been underpaid.
Reed Russell:
And so that does raise an issue, even in the Fifth Circuit, about whether you can have that private release.
Matt Greer:
Even in a global settlement of just a general kind of a settlement agreement and a separation of employment. That’s interesting. Okay.
Reed Russell:
And I do think it causes a lot of employers A lot of problems because they’re used to settling all kinds of claims, ADA, Title VII, ERISA, whatever, in these private settlement agreements. And they’d say, what’s so special about the FLSA? Right? And they have to be educated on this. And then it’s like, oh, well, now we have to file it with the court. And then you run into issues of confidentiality. And it does cause a lot of hurdles sometimes to getting a resolution. Yeah.
Matt Greer:
I guess I am curious, what is so special about the FLSA that there are these additional mechanisms? Is this a statutory provision in the law that’s different than Title VII or other perhaps employment-related statutes that drive us to this point? And I guess following up on that, obviously, there are splits in the circuits and the district courts and how they view that. I’m just curious if there is any underpinning there that’d be helpful for us to know about in the statutory structure of the FLSA that Brings us to this conversation.
Reed Russell:
Well, what I would say is that, you know, 216 does not say anything about settlement approval. 216 of the FLSA does provide for the Secretary of Labor to supervise payment of wages, but that is typically done in an enforcement proceeding, not a lawsuit. And so the Secretary of Labor oversees the payment of back wages and supervises the Sending out collection and processing of waivers of FLSA claims. At least from the employer’s perspective, I think it’s important to distinguish the 2 sections because when the Department of Labor is doing an enforcement proceeding, not a lawsuit, there’s no provision providing for liquidated damages. Under 216, if an employee brings an FLSA lawsuit and wins and you owe them $100 in back wages, The law provides as a default, it can be reduced, but in a default, you end up owing them $200. You owe them double damages. And that’s not available under 216. One point that I made, I’ve talked about with Doug, is one of the reasons the Department of Labor needs to supervise that is the employee doesn’t get the double damages or the attorney’s fees that come to its attorney under 216.
Reed Russell:
And so it may need more supervision. But getting back to the statute, the Supreme Court has said in Brooklyn-Neal and in Ganji, and that’s certainly been interpreted by the 11th Circuit over and over to say that the structure of the FLSA, the purpose for which it was passed, which was to protect minimum wage standards, requires oversight by the court in settling these claims. And just to put it in very plain terms, to avoid employers kind of taking their employees for a ride, right? Paying off the plaintiff’s attorney, paying them basically a subminimum wage to give up their claims, and undermining the purposes for which the FLSA was passed in the first place. That’s, I think, you know, a very thumbnail sketch of the kind of the theme behind why courts say FLSA claims need to be supervised. And I have seen this point made. I don’t know if it’s by a brief or by a court. It’s like, why is that different than race discrimination, which is certainly bad, and you certainly cannot waive your right to equal employment opportunity either under Title VII? But I have seen courts say, but in that case, the employer is paying something for the discrimination. I think that cuts both ways, but In any event, courts have found that the risk of undermining the minimum wage and overtime guarantees in the FLSA requires them to have some oversight, and they point back to Brooklyn Savings v.
Reed Russell:
O’Neill and D.A. Schulte v. Ganji.
Doug Werman:
And courts, again, have needed to find a way to apply this non-waivability rule that’s been created by the Supreme Court. And so, even though there’s nothing expressly in 216 that talks about court approval, I think they’re looking at 216 and say, well, here’s a process, here’s a procedure to use to make sure that the agreement is— a settlement agreement is supervised and in finality. And they’re just applying the 216 procedure to private litigation that’s filed under 216.
Matt Greer:
Okay. Interesting.
Reed Russell:
I agree with what Doug is saying, is that I think they’ve looked at 216 and said, Hey, there’s a supervision in the 216s, right? So we can adopt it to court approval as well. What I would tell them is, I think you’re reading that the wrong way. I think they put it in 216, meaning that it doesn’t apply in 216. So if the DOL is supervising a settlement in the enforcement proceeding, it can supervise it, but we don’t really need you to get involved. Once we have litigation. But so far, that certainly hasn’t been a selling proposition in the 11th Circuit to date.
Doug Werman:
Right. I mean, again, like, 216, you know, provides the express statutory mechanism by which acceptance of a supervised payment produces a waiver of the wage claim. That’s just a really straightforward path to finality. And so courts are applying that in the private litigation context.
Matt Greer:
Yeah, I know we’ve mentioned the role of the Department of Labor and the Secretary of Labor a little bit along the way. I was curious how much of an entity, I mean, in these types of cases that the Department of Labor does play out. I mean, obviously both of you, I’m guessing, do more of your work in the private action and the court system. But I’m kind of curious just process-wise in terms of where the agency-level involvement is in these types of claims.
Reed Russell:
Well, unlike with the EEOC, where an employee has to go to EEOC to file a charge, An employee does not have to go to the Department of Labor to file a claim under the FLSA. He or she can go straight to court. However, they can make a complaint to the Department of Labor, and the Department of Labor can come out and investigate and has very broad investigatory and enforcement powers to pursue an employer and ultimately bring a lawsuit in the name of the Secretary against the employer. And so, that 216 is The Secretary’s investigation and litigation and supervision vehicle, in rough terms. Typically, you don’t see private plaintiffs and the Department of Labor, not all the time, working together. Sometimes they will. It’s not reclusive. But the Department of Labor, if the Secretary sues you, that can cut off the ability of a private plaintiff to sue.
Reed Russell:
And so, there’s a little bit of tension. There. And I think if I’m the secretary and I’m looking at my scarce resources, there’s certainly enough private sector litigation that I don’t feel the need to act as a— using the secretary’s resources as an enforcement vehicle, certainly for a lot of cases. Most cases are brought by private plaintiffs, although there are some brought by the secretary in areas where he or she has decided it’s an enforcement priority.
Doug Werman:
And the Department of Labor does obtain releases from employees as part of their enforcement priorities and as part of their investigations. And those are, I think they’re still known as the WH-58 form, at least they used to be. And those are adequate to release individuals’ private claims when they’re obtained and signed by the employees.
Reed Russell:
And I should follow up on that because it is an interesting point. The WH-58 is the form. And it does release the claims. And as I said before, 216 does not provide for the recovery of liquidated damages in an enforcement proceeding. However, at least starting during the Obama administration and carrying on even well into the first Trump administration, that period, the Department of Labor in certain enforcement proceedings, in the investigations, was demanding payment of liquidated damages as part of resolving pre-suit enforcement proceedings with employers. That generated a lot of controversy, but they were doing it anyway. I believe that practice has generally come to an end. The employer’s argument was that’s not in the statute and you don’t really have the statutory right.
Reed Russell:
If you want to get those, file a lawsuit.
Matt Greer:
Okay.
Reed Russell:
The old argument was we only ask for these enforcement proceedings where we’ve already decided we’re going to sue you. So pay now or pay later. But that practice has somewhat come to an end. And so that, again, going back to the point before, the Department of Labor, when it supervises that settlement, it just gets the back wages, but it recovers them. It requires these releases. It oversees the process so that employees are not taken advantage of, at least from the Department of Labor’s perspective.
Matt Greer:
Yeah, I know we touched a little bit earlier about when these settlements do get before a court, when you’re in a situation where a judge does feel like they’re required to look at those or whatever reason they decide to look at that. I think, Doug, you mentioned fair and reasonable was the general standard. Is that correct? I just, I guess I’m curious, what does that look like? What the level of involvement the judge has in kind of evaluating that? Is there, are there follow-up procedures, hearings on this, or how does that actually look in practice?
Doug Werman:
The standard that you hear most often is a fair and reasonable resolution of a bona fide dispute. Okay. And that’s right out of the Lynn’s Food decision from the 11th Circuit. The golden rule is, in terms of presenting it to a judge, if the parties have decided that they are going to do that, is know your judge, because some judges will require a pretty rigorous showing about What’s the scope of the release, what the value of the claims were, what the bona fide dispute was, and sort of like what the dispute was over what the violation or the— what the alleged violation of the FLSA was in the first instance. And so I don’t really, at least personally, there’s not one rule that I follow. There’s not one template document that I’m using to file in front of every judge to get court approval. We know our judges. and we know what’s the minimum amount of information we need to show that judge to get approval.
Doug Werman:
And the judges who we don’t have experience with, we’re doing generally a very, very deep dive on Westlaw dockets to try to identify, you know, their history of whether or not he or she approved— requires approval at all. Some judges, as we’ve mentioned before, you know, police their dockets and Some don’t. Some you can just file the Rule 41 dismissal and be done. So we really generally first identify what our judge is all about, what he or she’s going to require. And then a lot of it is, is what’s the comfort level? And Reed can speak to this. What’s the comfort level of the defendant, of the employer, in wanting to have the court approval? Some want that as opposed to just filing the Rule 41 dismissal. If that’s even going to be accepted by the court.
Reed Russell:
It really does depend on the judge. It’s not even, even here in where I am in Tampa, in the Middle District of Florida, the judge and not the court is what you need to look at because there’s wide variation between the judges and how they view this approval requirement under the 11th Circuit and whether they view it as sort of a solemn duty they have to really police the agreement, or if they view it as almost an annoyance. And they’ll take a look at the papers and they want to keep their docket clear. And they view this as something that is negotiated between arm’s-length parties, and they’ll give it a quick look and you’ll get an approval order same day or within a day or 2. Versus some will have a hearing and ask a bunch of probing questions. Sometimes that comes down to an issue over The attorney’s fees, which can be a touchpoint of controversy. And some of the courts, I guess the 8th Circuit, and I know the 11th Circuit certainly have a rule that allows the parties to say, at least in the 11th Circuit, that they negotiated the attorney’s fees and costs separately from the amounts that are being paid to the individual employees. And if you are able to represent that in good faith to the court, Their review of the attorney’s fees will be relatively cursory, at least in the 11th Circuit.
Reed Russell:
Whereas if you’re not able to say that, they’re liable to do a much deeper dive to make sure they’re worried about collusion between the plaintiff’s counsel and the employer that, you know, basically, to put it bluntly, that the employer bought the plaintiff’s counsel off and then got an unreasonable discount on the claims of the employees. That’s where they can dig in.
Matt Greer:
Sounds like there could be some awkward questioning at a hearing about the issues related to that, trying to figure out how you suss out the collusion piece. But hopefully that doesn’t come up too often. But yeah, that’s interesting.
Reed Russell:
We have to say in the papers that there was no collusion, and we usually include some facts about how there was not arm’s-length bargaining, some level of discovery, either formal or informal, Maybe the deposition’s taken. If there was a mediation that was conducted, that helps, right? Because you had a third party that can sometimes be with a magistrate judge or with a private mediator, but you can get around it. But we have to represent that there was none.
Doug Werman:
And again, as Reed mentioned, I mean, the attorney’s fees issue in particular is just policed much more heavily in certain circuits, the 8th Circuit and the 11th Circuit and the 2nd Circuit. You know, not so much in the 7th Circuit and many other places. And then also, as Reed mentioned, which I agree with, even within the circuits, there’s just an extreme variance judge by judge by judge.
Matt Greer:
Yeah, that’s where, yeah, the research into the local practice and the judges sounds very important. So, yeah.
Reed Russell:
Well, Doug mentioned this very briefly. The 11th Circuit is the 11th Circuit, but not every circuit has a developed rule. on approval. And so you have sometimes even within an individual district court, different district judges coming out different ways on whether approval is required at all.
Matt Greer:
Wow.
Reed Russell:
And so it really is critical. It’s, you know, everybody says know your judge, but in this case, it really can drive major strategic decisions in the lawsuit.
Matt Greer:
Wow. That’s fascinating. Yeah. Even within the same district. Okay.
Doug Werman:
And it can be very impactful for lawyers who are negotiating pre-suit resolution of Fair Labor Standards Act cases, whether it be an individual case or a collective action, because if the case is going to be resolved pre-suit, but the employer still wants to then obtain judicial approval, then a decision has to be made or can be made about where, what venue to file the case in for approval.
Matt Greer:
Oh, okay. Another strategy point there, huh? Yeah.
Doug Werman:
Yes.
Matt Greer:
So this might be a little bit of a silly question, but I’ll ask it anyway. So, so what if you do go through the approval process and the judge looks at it and decides not to approve the settlement agreement? What happens then? Are you then forced into a litigation situation? Do you get a second chance to make the case for, for the settlement agreement being fair and reasonable under the standard? Or I guess just, I’m curious what happens at that point. It must be an awkward situation to be in. I mean,
Reed Russell:
most settlement agreements have a provision that it’s got to be approved, right, to be enforceable. It doesn’t happen very often, but I think what I have seen most of the time is the judges don’t just kick you out. They send you away and say, come back and fix these problems. Those problems might be relatively easy to resolve. They might be significant. And so it’s just going to depend on the case. I think, you know, it depends on how Maybe if you got too good of a deal from the employer side, you may end up getting not quite the great deal you thought you had. On the plaintiff side, I don’t know what kind of key things have driven settlements back from the initial approval, but usually you get a chance to fix them.
Doug Werman:
I agree. I think you see that most often in courts, like for example, in the Southern District of New York, that are finding like collateral terms of settlement agreements to be improper. Maybe that’s a general release as opposed to a specific release of just the FLSA claims, or there’s not disparagement language that the court wants. And these judges are spending, I think, an inordinate amount of time writing decisions about what are all the problems with the settlement agreement. And so, like Reed suggested, the judges are giving the lawyers a roadmap about what needs to be fixed, and then it’s just a question of whether or not the employer is willing to Usually agree to terms that make the deal less attractive to it.
Matt Greer:
Right. Yeah.
Reed Russell:
And that’s a good segue into a point that unlike maybe a Title VII settlement agreement that you have with an employee that has what we would consider kind of garden variety terms like confidentiality and non-disparagement and a general release of claims, these courts that approve or require approval of FLSA settlements some of them, not all of them, will not let you have some of those standard terms that, or what I call standard things that people have come to expect. And so that can be a discussion point and a big decision point for an employer who wants to resolve this obviously on as quiet a basis as possible. And they’ve already had the discussion, well, you know, we’re gonna have to get court approval. And by the way, we can’t have a nondisparagement clause. And by the way, we may not be able to have a general release. There are ways around that if you package the settlement correctly with the correct judge, but those are all decision points and education points where an employer is unfamiliar with this space. Those are unhappy surprises if they come up late in the discussion. So, it’s important, I think, you know, for employers listening to this, if you have a client that hasn’t had this experience, you need to educate them on the FLSA settlement process.
Reed Russell:
early on before you get into these discussions, because you don’t want to find that out after you think you have a deal and then can’t have many of your favorite usual provisions in the agreement.
Matt Greer:
Yeah. Interesting. All right. As we close out our episode, I did want to give both of you an opportunity if you wanted to provide some tips to our listeners and to each other. So I don’t know, Doug, do you want to start us off? Do you have a tip for Reed?
Doug Werman:
Well, one tip that I would like to give to, not really to Reed, but to defense lawyers who are wanting to settle FLSA litigation, especially collective action FLSA litigation, is what kind of finality do they really want and what is the scope of the finality that they want? And, you know, from our perspective, we’re always interested in giving the employer as much finality as possible. And so that means, for example, getting payments out to as many people as possible. And oftentimes in the context of these collective action settlements, you know, we want to do checks-out-the-door settlements as opposed to requiring employees to first consent to participate in the litigation before they settle the claims. That’s something that, you know, we like to address very early on. You know, we’re really interested in sort of setting the table for that in terms of what our expectations are in terms of resolution.
Matt Greer:
Yeah, great. Reed, what about you? Do you have any tips for Doug or for the plaintiffs’ bar generally?
Reed Russell:
Not to give Doug, but I would say that when you’re dealing with an employer, recognize there’s only one side writing a check. And so giving some latitude to the employer’s desires regarding provisions in the settlement that you can live with. Certainly, an employer’s not happy about having any publication or notification or approval of these settlements. They would like to do them confidentially and bury them in the ground. So be open to the idea that they’re working their way back from a confidential settlement. And so the extent that you can extend flexibility about these provisions that don’t undermine the ability to get it approved, be flexible about that. And then just recognize that the lawyer you’re dealing with is one person in a group. of decision makers, an advisor.
Reed Russell:
So defense lawyers often can’t just agree to things on the fly. They’ve got to talk to their in-house counsel. The in-house counsel may have operational management personnel that they have to get buy-off on. So you’re going to have some structural challenges sometimes. You know, you may have more flexibility on the plaintiff’s side that doesn’t exist on the employer’s side. So just keep that in mind when you’re negotiating.
Matt Greer:
Great. Yeah, thanks to you both for Closing out with those practical tips and thoughts as we end the conversation here. So I do want to thank you again, both for your time and being part of this episode. It was very interesting. I certainly learned a lot. I’m guessing most of our listeners did as well. So thank you so much for joining us and sharing your knowledge and wisdom.
Doug Werman:
Thank you.
Reed Russell:
Thank you very much.
Matt Greer:
I also want to take a moment to thank our listeners for taking the moment to listen in, and I hope you all learned as much as I did. If you enjoyed the conversation, Be sure to let your colleagues know about the podcast and share the episode with them, and we’ll see everyone next time. Thank you.
|
ABA Labor and Employment Law Podcast |
ABA Labor & Employment Law Podcast is a thoughtful, balanced discussion with guests from two sides of a labor-related issue in the news.