Subscribe to receive featured episodes and staff favorites once a month.
Newsletter Signup
A prospective client calls your firm for the first time. You’re in a deposition, and the call goes to voicemail. You may never learn it happened.
This is one of the most common situations a new solo faces. The caller needed an answer, didn’t get one, and moved on to the next firm on their list.
Most people do their research before they pick up the phone. They read a few reviews, look at a website or two, and follow up on a referral. By the time your line actually rings, the decision is largely made. The caller is confirming a few things: that you’re reachable, that you sound capable, and that you’re the kind of firm that they want to work with.
A voicemail greeting answers those questions, though rarely in your favor.
When a call reaches an established firm, someone answers while the partner is in court, and the caller is none the wiser. They feel looked after, and that reassurance is much of what they’re paying for.
A solo practice has no buffer. The hours that you’re billing for – a hearing, a client meeting, focused drafting – are the same hours you can’t answer the phone. That’s a matter of coverage, not effort. No one can be in a deposition and on the call at the same time.
It helps to remember what callers want. When contacting a law firm, 87% of people would rather speak to a person than an automated system (OnePoll, 2026). Legal matters are personal and often frightening, and a calm, human voice does real work before a word has been said about the case.
Professional presence comes from consistency: handling the 8pm Sunday call with the same care as the one at 10am on a Tuesday.
In practice, a first contact that holds up does a few things well. A real person answers, without hurry. The caller’s situation is acknowledged calmly and taken seriously. The client ends the call knowing what happens next, whether that’s a booked consultation or a document to send over. And their details are recorded accurately: name, matter, and how they found you.
None of it is complicated. It simply has to happen every time, including the times you can’t be there yourself.
Which approach fits depends on your practice area, your call volume, and your budget.
Answer every call yourself. It costs nothing and works well while you’re quiet, but it falls apart the moment you’re with a client or away from your desk.
Bring on part-time or shared staff. That’s steadier through business hours, though it adds payroll and people management before many new firms are ready, and it still leaves lunches, evenings, and weekends uncovered.
Use a live answering service built for law firms. This is where a service like LEX Reception fits: trained human receptionists, not bots, answer your calls and take intake around the clock. Callers reach a person, and you receive clean intake while you’re in court, without adding anyone to your payroll.
Each of these can work. What matters is choosing deliberately, depending on your circumstances.
Before changing anything, find out what your callers actually experience. Spend twenty minutes as your own client:
Somewhere, someone who needs a lawyer hasn’t dialed yet. They’ll compare you against two or three other firms, and you won’t choose the moment they call. What they find when they do is something you can settle now, in your first weeks of practice. It’s one of the first impressions a new firm can shape with intention — and worth getting right while it’s still straightforward to do.
*Source: OnePoll, 2026
AUTHOR
Fiona Stevenson
Associate Director of Marketing at LEX Reception
